Have you ever started cleaning out your computer, only to find yourself three hours later doing something that had absolutely nothing to do with what you started?
Welcome to my world!
All I wanted to do was clean up some passwords and make sure I could still get into my accounts. Simple enough, right?
Wrong.
Somewhere between forgotten passwords, rewards programs, and accounts I hadn’t looked at in ages, I stumbled across my AARP membership.
And that got me thinking.
Am I actually saving money with all these memberships, or am I just collecting little plastic cards and apps that make me feel like I’m saving money?
I pay $20 a year for AARP. That’s not a fortune, but twenty dollars is twenty dollars. If I’m paying for a membership, I’d like to know whether it’s doing anything for me.
So, naturally, I did what any reasonable woman would do.
I turned a little password cleanup into a full-blown travel savings investigation.
Buck wasn’t impressed. He was probably wondering why we weren’t investigating an actual road somewhere.
First Stop: The Gas Pumps
Before we ever got to hotels, I discovered I had quite a collection of fuel rewards programs.
Love’s, Pilot Flying J, Casey’s, Hy-Vee Fuel Saver, GasBuddy, and AARP-related fuel offers.
Good grief! How many ways can one woman supposedly save money on gasoline?
Love’s: A Discount I’d Forgotten About
I opened my Love’s website and discovered a gasoline offer for 10 cents off per gallon in my rewards app.
Ten cents might not sound like much, but if you’re filling up while traveling, it adds up.
For example, on a 15-gallon fill-up, that’s $1.50 saved.
Fill up ten times, and you’ve saved $15.
The catch? You have to remember to use the offer.
I even found an old Love’s receipt from a road trip. Apparently, I remembered how to find the gas station but had forgotten about the rewards account.
I activated the offer, so now I just need to remember it exists!
Pilot Flying J: Another Ten Cents
Pilot Flying J also showed a 10-cent-per-gallon gasoline offer in its app.
That’s another potentially useful discount, particularly when traveling along the interstate.
But offers can require activation, and not every promotion works automatically.
Lesson learned: Having a rewards app and actually using its benefits are two different things.
GasBuddy: A Little More Complicated
I’ve used GasBuddy to look for cheaper gas stations, which is helpful by itself.
But then there are additional programs, payment cards, and a paid Premium membership.
Some advertisements promise savings of up to a certain amount per gallon.
Those two little words—up to—are important.
They don’t mean everybody saves that amount every time.
I don’t currently pay for GasBuddy Premium, and I wasn’t about to sign up just to conduct this experiment.
Sometimes the best savings decision is not spending more money to chase a discount.
And Then There’s AARP
AARP offers fuel-related benefits through participating programs such as Shell Fuel Rewards and Exxon Mobil Rewards+.
Some offers involve linking accounts, meeting eligibility requirements, or signing up as a new member.
But here’s the thing: I can’t count money I haven’t actually saved.
An advertised welcome bonus doesn’t mean I’ve earned it. And a potential discount isn’t the same thing as money left in my wallet.
That became the rule for the rest of my experiment.
Kelly Jo’s note: While Buck considers himself an expert in kennel cleanup, eating poop isn’t a habit we encourage. If your dog does this frequently, check with your veterinarian about possible causes and ways to prevent it.

What If You’d Rather Let Someone Else Drive?
Saving money on gas is great, but sometimes the best part of traveling is sitting back and enjoying the scenery!
If you’re exploring a new destination and don’t want to worry about driving, parking, or navigating unfamiliar roads, consider a private car tour with a local guide.
It’s another way to experience the adventure while leaving the driving to someone else.
Affiliate disclosure: I may earn a commission if you book through this link, at no additional cost to you.
Travel Note: GoWithGuide is an independent travel service and is not affiliated with AARP or its member discounts.
Click below to find your own Private Car Tour!
Explore More With a Private Car Tour
Next Stop: Colorado Hotels
Since I love traveling, I decided to test hotel prices.
I chose Estes Park, Colorado, for a hypothetical two-night stay, November 9–11, 2026, for two adults.
No, I wasn’t booking a vacation.
I was doing research.
Although after looking at Colorado hotels for this long, I was certainly ready for one!
I compared hotel loyalty rates, senior discounts, AARP rates, and Hotels.com.
And this is where things got interesting.
Quality Inn: The Regular Promotion Wins
At Quality Inn near Rocky Mountain National Park, I found these prices for a king room:
| Booking option | Two-night total |
|---|---|
| Choice Hotels regular promotion | $282.12 |
| AARP discount | $298.72 |
| Senior 60+ discount | $298.72 |
The hotel advertised savings with the AARP and senior rates.
But the regular promotion was $16.60 cheaper.
Wait a minute.
I thought I was supposed to be getting a discount!
Apparently, just because a rate has the word senior or AARP attached to it doesn’t mean it’s the best available price.
That’s something worth remembering before clicking the reservation button.
You can explore rates yourself at Choice Hotels.
La Quinta: A Battle Over 97 Cents
Next, I looked at La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Loveland/Estes Park.
This property was farther from Estes Park itself, so location and extra driving would have to be considered before choosing it for a real trip.
For a two-queen-bed room, the prices we found included:
| Booking option | Two-night total |
|---|---|
| Wyndham Rewards | $220.52 |
| Hotels.com initial two-queen quote | $221.49 |
| Wyndham AARP rate | $225.04 |
Ninety-seven cents!
That was the difference between the Wyndham Rewards price and the initial Hotels.com quote.
But there were still cancellation policies, payment terms, and possible rewards to consider.
And then Hotels.com threw another twist into the mix.
Save Now or Save Later?
After signing into Hotels.com, I found a king-room offer that let me choose between taking a discount immediately or banking rewards for another trip.
Here’s what the screen showed:
| Hotels.com option | Total |
|---|---|
| Save $39.14 now | $221.49 |
| Bank rewards for later | $260.63 |
With the second option, I could earn $42.95 in OneKeyCash after completing the stay.
So I’d pay $39.14 more for the hotel now in exchange for $42.95 in future travel rewards.
That’s a potential $3.81 advantage—but only if I actually use those rewards.
And OneKeyCash isn’t cash I can take to the grocery store. It’s credit toward eligible future travel.
Suddenly, choosing the best deal wasn’t quite as simple as comparing two prices.
Holiday Inn: The Senior Discount That Cost More
Then I checked Holiday Inn Estes Park through IHG Hotels & Resorts.
And I nearly fell out of my chair.
| Booking option | Two-night total |
|---|---|
| IHG One Rewards regular member | $327.18 |
| Hotels.com | $341.62 |
| IHG Senior Member Discount | $372.00 |
Yes, you read that correctly.
The Senior Member Discount was $44.82 MORE than the regular member rate!
Now, to be fair, the senior rate did allow a later cancellation deadline, so the booking conditions weren’t identical.
But $44.82 is still a pretty big difference for a rate with the word discount in its name.
And the senior rate screen cheerfully told me I was getting a great price.
Well, bless its heart.
Don’t Forget Those Extra Fees
The Holiday Inn comparison also reminded me to look beyond the nightly room price.
The Hotels.com quote showed $270 for the room itself.
But after taxes, resort fees, and taxes on those fees, the total was $341.62.
That’s $71.62 above the room subtotal.
Some of the hotel’s amenities sounded fun—s’mores, fire pits, and seasonal recreational equipment—but I still want to know what I’m paying before I decide whether those extras are worth it.
Another discovery: at this particular Holiday Inn, Hotels.com’s Pay Now and Pay Later options had the same final total.
The difference was the payment schedule, not the overall cost.
So, Is My AARP Membership Worth $20?
After all that investigating, here’s what I learned.
I haven’t proven that my AARP membership pays for itself through hotel discounts.
In fact, for the hotel dates and rooms I checked, the AARP rates we compared didn’t beat the best available regular promotions or loyalty-member prices.
That doesn’t mean AARP is worthless.
There are other benefits, including discounts in different travel categories, dining, shopping, and services. Some may be useful to me throughout the year.
But I’m not going to count an advertised discount as savings unless it actually saves me money compared with what I could have paid without it.
And I certainly don’t want to spend $40 more just so I can tell myself I used a discount!
What I’ll Do Differently Before My Next Road Trip
I’ve learned a few things from this little adventure:
- Compare the final price, including taxes and fees—not just the advertised nightly rate.
- Check regular promotions before using senior or membership discounts. The special rate might not be the lowest.
- Match the same dates, room type, and cancellation policy. I even caught myself looking at the wrong nights during this experiment!
- Don’t treat rewards points as cash. They’re only valuable if I can use them.
- Remember the gas rewards apps I already have. A forgotten discount saves absolutely nothing.
- Consider location. A cheaper hotel farther away may mean more driving, gasoline, and time.
The Roadside Gossip Verdict
So, did I solve the mystery of whether my $20 AARP membership pays for itself?
Not completely.
But I discovered something more useful.
A discount is only a discount if it actually saves you money.
I also learned that having a wallet full of membership cards doesn’t make me a savvy traveler.
Knowing when to use them does.
And to think, this whole adventure started because I wanted to clean up a few passwords!
My computer may still need organizing, but at least now I know to question a hotel website when it congratulates me for paying more.
As for Buck?
I’m pretty sure he’d vote for fewer hours comparing hotel rates and more time exploring the great outdoors.
And honestly, he’s probably right.
Until the next adventure, keep your eyes on the road, your sense of humor handy, and your money where it belongs—in your pocket!
Speaking of travel adventures, if you’d rather read about an actual trip instead of watching me chase hotel discounts, check out my California Zephyr adventure in All Aboard the Adventure!
Research note: Hotel prices were checked October 21, 2026, for a hypothetical November 9–11 stay. Rates, promotions, availability, fees, and rewards may change. No hotel reservations were made. Fuel savings mentioned are examples or available offers, not necessarily savings I personally received.


